Imágenes de páginas
PDF
EPUB

THURSDAY, NOVEMBER 12, 1891.

THE HYGIENE OF WATER-SUPPLY.

An Elementary Hand-book on Potable Water. By Floyd Davis, M.Sc, Ph.D. (Boston, U.S.: Silver, Burdett, and Co., 1891.)

THE

'HE aphorism that "history repeats itself" is being very strikingly illustrated in the matter of hygiene at the present day. Questions respecting water-supply and the public health generally, which in this country were absorbing much of scientific attention some fifteen or twenty years ago, have only within the last decade begun to be seriously dealt with even in the most civilized of Continental countries and in the United States. Indeed, although we are indebted for much of the recent progress which has been made in what may be called the theory of hygiene to our Continental neighbours, yet in matters of actual practice we still hold, undisputedly, the first place among nations. The practice of hygienic principles cannot be introduced by Act of Parliament or Imperial ukase; it is the growth of years, or rather generations, and is quite independent of the establishment of hygienic institutes and bacteriological laboratories. In a few hours of Continental travel, it is possible to visit University towns provided with hygienic laboratories, munificently equipped, in which food-stuffs are daily submitted to elaborate analysis, whilst water and milk are searchingly interrogated as to the microorganisms which they contain ; and yet side by side with these refinements we find sanitary conditions, even in the houses of the well-to-do, which would hardly be found in the alleys and purlieus of one of our manufacturing centres. It is far from my wish or purpose to deprecate the establishment of institutions for the prosecution of hygienic inquiries on a scientific basis; on the contrary, such places are calculated to enormously accelerate the achievement of sanitary improvements, and to economize time, money, and human life, which are ruthlessly wasted when these improvements are attained as the result of empiricism and the operation of natural forces. Our position of supremacy in practical sanitation is mainly due to the long period of domestic repose and prosperity which we have enjoyed, and which has led us to turn our attention to the prevention of the unnecessary sacrifice of human beings even in civil life; but who can doubt that this position would have been much more rapidly gained if these endeavours had been always guided by scientific knowledge and systematic experimental inquiry? Even as it is, the path to our present position has been much shortened, and has been rendered less costly both as regards life and money, by the time and attention which have been bestowed upon sanitary matters by men of high scientific attainments. It is earnestly to be hoped that the recent Hygienic Congress held in our midst will have convinced those who control the purse of this country that a national effort must be made to maintain our position in the scientific as well as the practical progress of the century. We have not to

deplore any shortcoming in the quality of the scientific work which emanates from us; in originality and as pioneers in all departments of science we are second to none; but quantitatively we are lamentably deficient, and in consequence, it is only too frequently the case that we have to leave to others the cultivation of those fields which we have ourselves had a large share in discovering. This is most conspicuously the case in the matter of hygiene; and after the highly discreditable obstruction, with which the foundation of our National Institute of Preventive Medicine was recently harassed, has now happily been swept away, we trust that public if not Government support will be forthcoming in the immediate future, to render that Institution, with its tremendous potentiality for benefiting mankind, second in usefulness and dignity to none in the civilized world. The State organization of science in the New World has made great strides during recent years, and scientific men in this country cannot fail to be impressed with the immense volume of work-more especially in applied science-which annually flows from the laboratories of the United States. The appearance of the book before us is, presumably, evidence of this great activity, showing as it does that there is a considerable body of men anxious to have presented to them in a concise and handy form all the main facts which have been accumu. lated-and which are dispersed in innumerable reports, blue-books, journals, and other forms of literature-concerning potable water. The difficulty of access to the original sources of this information renders such a work of great importance at the present time, but one which it is extremely difficult to do justice to. The present volume, we regret, does not come up to what we could wish for in a work of the kind. The questions which have to be discussed are in many cases necessarily more or less matters of opinion, in which conflicting evidence ought to be balanced and submitted to careful and critical analysis; unfortunately, however, for the exercise of this judicial power the author exhibits but little aptitude or inclination. The pages are sometimes filled with authoritative statements made by their respective authors on insufficient data, which statements have been copied, often not even from the original sources, without a word of elucidation or criticism. Such material, placed in the hands of the unwary reader, may lead to very serious consequences. Of this character is the statement that "the power of certain samples of water to dissolve lead is directly proportional to the number of micro-organisms that the samples respectively contain," which might well have been omitted from this work; and its introduction as almost the only piece of information concerning the action of water on lead is singularly inappropriate. Again, on another page, we are categorically informed that "even milk is sometimes the agent of this disease (typhoid fever), in which case the typhoid poison remains undestroyed in passing from the polluted water from which the cows drink, to the milk-secreting glands"; whilst no mention is made of the real mode of transmission by the watering of milk and the rinsing of cans with contaminated water. In most cases the principles laid down are sound and reasonable; but the author has permitted himself to be carried some

26

what too far in his advocacy of pure water, when he
says that "scientific investigation also reveals the fact
that, as a community is supplied with pure water, there
is not only a decrease in the disease and death-rate,
but often a most surprisingly rapid increase in thrift,
We should be
morality, and degree of civilization."
glad indeed if he were correct in his statement that
since the introduction of an efficient health administration
in England, the prevalence of typhoid has been reduced
to such an extent that "for weeks and even months
not a single case now occurs in the city of London." We
can readily understand that our rivers must appear
insignificant enough to the inhabitants of a country con-
taining such mighty streams as the St. Lawrence, the
Mississippi, and the Ohio; and although we are fully
alive to some of them being disgracefully fouled, we
certainly are somewhat startled to have our watercourses,
which are dear to many of us, disposed of in the following
sentences :-"The pollution of English streams is carried
to such an enormous extent that the waters of many,
where city sewage enters them, are actually offensive,
and during the summer months, owing to the stench, the
passenger traffic is forced to the railroads. In some of
these streams the whole surface of the water, for some
distance below sewage entrance, is in a state of commo-
tion, owing to the evolution of gas bubbles, and the water
is so foul that it cannot be used in the boilers of the
little steamers that ply across the rivers. Immediately
below the entrance of sewage no life can exist in the
water, on account of the presence of ferrous sulphate (sic),
In dealing with the much
which is a disinfectant."
vexed subject of the apparent self-purification of streams,
the author shows a very just appreciation of the matter
when he points out that there" is no guarantee that run-
ning water is perfectly wholesome at any distance below
a point where it is certainly polluted with the contents of
sewers and privy-vaults, or the decomposition of vegetable
and animal matter. The question as to what extent must
impure water be diluted or oxidized to render it safe for
domestic purposes, cannot be answered. Mere dilution
of polluted water does not render inoperative the action
of living bacteria...." We are glad to see that the
author points ou the importance of boiling all drinking-
water which is open to suspicion, for it cannot be too
frequently reiterated that perhaps the two most effective
measures which the private individual can take in avoid-
ing zymotic disease consist in boiling the water and
milk that are used for drinking. The largely increasing
consumption of ice, which in America has assumed
enormous proportions, is a matter which also calls for
very careful attention, since recent experiments have
shown that, although the living bacteria in ice are con-
siderably less numerous than in the water from which
the ice has been derived, still the process of freezing,
even if long continued, affords no sort of guarantee that
the dangerous forms originally present in the water shall
have been destroyed. Thus the bacillus of typhoid fever
has been found still alive in ice which had remained
continuously frozen for a period of 103 days.

PERCY F. FRANKLAND.

CAUSATION of sleep.

The Intracranial Circulation and its Relation to the Physiology of the Brain. By James Cappie, M.D. (Edinburgh James Thin, 1890.)

THE

HE factors concerned in the production of sleep have from time to time engaged the attention of physiologists, and various theories have been advanced to explain the phenomena. The author of the work now before us, so far back as 1854, published a short essay on "The Immediate Cause of Sleep," which he subsequently expanded into a volume entitled "The Causation of Sleep" (Edinburgh, 1882). In the work now under consideration, although with a different title, the author travels over much the same ground as that surveyed in his previous writings on this subject, and adds to it some additional chapters.

In his successive publications Dr. Cappie accepts the position usually taken up by physiologists, that the state of sleep is accompanied by a diminished brain circulation; but he combats the view that sleep is due to a diminution of the whole mass of blood within the cranial cavity, and that the compensation for this diminution is got by an increase in the amount of cerebro-spinal fluid in the ventricular and sub-arachnoid spaces of the brain. His objection to this opinion is based upon its not being reconcilable with either the physics or the physiology of the parts situated within the cranium. As regards the physics, he adopts the view advocated by Drs. Alexander Monro (secundus), Abercrombie, and Kellie, that, inasmuch as the brain lies within a closed cavity, which possesses rigid bony walls, the contents cannot be affected directly by the pressure of the atmosphere, which can only influence the interior of the cranium through the blood-vessels, so that a force is constantly in operation to maintain the amount of blood within the intracranial The author believes that the effect of the vessels. pressure on the blood-vessels, say of the neck and head, is opposed to the movement of the blood in the veins, and that the tendency of the pressure is to keep the At blood within the veins which ramify in the vascular membrane enveloping the brain, called the pia mater. the same time, however, the arterial stream drives the blood onwards into the capillaries and the veins, which tends to dilate the latter vessels, and, in conjunction with the backward pressure on the great veins, to retard the flow of blood through the veins of the pia mater, and In this way he infers that, consequently through the great venous sinuses of the head, into the jugular veins. whilst the brain itself becomes less vascular, the mass of blood within the cranial cavity continues the same, but its mode of distribution is altered: a less proportion is within the arteries and capillaries, whilst an increase takes place in the contents of the veins of the pia mater.

The author acknowledges, in connection with the nutrition of the brain, that molecular actions of a subtile kind take place between the blood and blood-vessels and the nervous tissues, and that these are much less active during sleep than when awake. The lessened activity in the nutrition of the nerve protoplasm diminishes the activity of the capillary circulation. He regards, however, the change in the balance of the circulation

between the arteries and capillaries on the one hand, and the veins on the other, as the key-stone of the theory of the causation of sleep. The altered balance of the circulation occasions a change in the balance of active pressure, which is not so much within the brain substance as on the surface. It is less expansive and more compressing, and with this compression consciousness is suspended.

In proof of his theory, the author adduces observations made by Dr. Hughlings Jackson and himself on the retina-the blood-vessels of which are so intimately connected with those of the brain--both during sleep and in a state of coma, from which it would appear that in these conditions the retina was paler, its arteries smaller, but its veins were larger, more tortuous, and distended. In another case recorded by Dr. Kennedy, where a portion of the skull and dura mater had been removed, and the pia mater consequently exposed, it was noticed that the veins in the latter were during sleep congested and assumed a dark hue.

In a concluding chapter, entitled "Some Points in Mental Physiology," which was not contained in his previous work "On the Immediate Cause of Sleep," the author considers how far the peculiarities of the encephalic circulation may affect the functional activity of the different parts of the brain. Starting from the position that the brain is a composite organ, and that distinct portions are put into a state of functional activity in connection with the discharge of their respective duties, the question of balance of the circulation has again to be considered. For the part which is more immediately concerned in the production of the particular cerebral operation must become the seat of vascular excitement, and the amount of blood flowing through its vessels will be greater than that transmitted through the vessels of those other parts of the brain which are for the time being not so functionally active. Hence a certain tension of the area or centre which is actively working must arise, and the encephalic circulation is focussed in the direction of activity. The parts which surround the operating centre would act as a background of resistance, and would afford such support as will secure the immediate liberating action in the discharging centre.

[ocr errors]

The author applies his views on the encephalic circulation to the explanation of the phenomena of Hypnotism. The first incident in the hypnotic state is a steady prolonged effort of volition in which the attention is concentrated in a very restricted direction. The immediate consequence is fatigue of the nerve-centres concerned in keeping up the strain. Their molecular motions become enfeebled, the circulation through them is less active, and a condition approaching that of sleep is produced. If then, in the form of a "suggestion" from another, some stimulus calls into activity a part of the brain not fatigued in the effort of attention, the vascular activity in it will be increased, and its function will be intensified. An assertion boldly made to a hypnotized person may influence belief in opposition to former experience, and if it be towards an ideational centre, some particular notion may so monopolize the consciousness that discrimination and judgment may become almost as completely in abeyance as in ordinary dreaming.

OUR BOOK SHELF.

Physiography: Elementary Stage. By J. Spencer,

B.Sc., F.C.S. (London: Percival and Co., 1891.) As an introductory science, physiography is one requiring very careful treatment. Its range is undoubtedly wide, but it is correspondingly shallow, and should rather lead up to scientific thought than aim at giving an incoherent collection of facts. In the book before us, the author, who is head master of one of our most successful technical colleges, begins well by recommending that teachers should endeavour to make the subject a practical one, by the performance of experiments, excursions into the neighbouring country, and the collection of specimens of rocks, minerals, and fossils. The experimental shape which the book has consequently taken is one of its most noticeable features; but it certainly falls short of the expectations raised. The chemical and physical parts appear to be excellent, but there is little to assist either teacher or student in gleaning information from the inspection of natural phenomena. A peat bog, for instance, is a fruitful subject for study under proper guidance; but this is not afforded by the scanty remarks on p. 89. In dealing with a wide subject, brevity is essential, but this does not necessitate the omission of the fundamental points, and looseness of expression. The book, however, shows many signs of a want of care in this respect. In the note on Foucault's pendulum (p. 210), for example, the whole point of the explanation of the plane of swing. On p. 113, it is stated that “ subis lost by the absence of a reference to the permanence marine volcanoes produce new land, the erupted matter being piled up sufficiently high to form islands"; the omission of the qualifying word "sometimes" might obviously lead to a misconception. Test questions, original and selected, are given at the end of each chapter. The book is well illustrated, and, with careful revision, should make a useful addition to existing text-books. Mayhew's Illustrated Horse Doctor. Revised and Improved by James Irvine Lupton, F.R.C.V.S. (London: Griffith, Farran, and Co.)

THE continued existence of domestic medicine, whether the subjects of its application be human beings or domesticated animals, cannot well be doubted. We may, however, be permitted to doubt whether true economy lies in this direction. Nevertheless, as residents in the colonies, and even in many rural districts of our own country, are often far removed from the qualified veterinarian, and considerable time must necessarily elapse before his services when sought can be forthcoming, it is obviously advisable that whatever measures are taken by the stock-owner to ameliorate the sufferings of the animal during this interval of time should be rational, and follow lines similar to those which the professional man would adopt. Wrong methods of procedure would serve only to handicap and hamper his efforts. The book before us can be recommended to guide the horse-owner in such emergencies; though we note with pleasure that the reviser, on p. 553, points out that "the reader will always best consult his interest and pocket by at once consulting a qualified veterinarian." Agreeing with this proposition, we cannot but consider superfluous the introduction of minute directions for the performance of such delicate and difficult operations as the extirpation of the eye-ball, the division of the plantar nerves (neurotomy) in some forms of foot-lameness, and section of contracted tendons (tenotomy). We can scarcely conceive an owner, however intelligent and courageous he may be, proceeding to cast, chloroform, and perform any of the above-mentioned operations.

Horse-owners will do well to note the stress which is laid upon the construction, ventilation, and drainage of

stables, and the varied information given on the prevention of disease. The reviser has scant sympathy with the use of the actual cautery; but here he is on debatable ground, and, notwithstanding his strictures, we fancy veterinarians will not lightly lay aside an agent which, rightly or wrongly, most of them believe to be potent for good.

The illustrations form the least satisfactory portion of the work. Many of them are grotesque and ludicrous to the last degree, and ought to have been eliminated from the present revised edition. Some, such as those indicative of the symptoms of colic, are good, and well convey their intended meaning.

W. F. G.

Handleiding tot de Kennis der Flora van Nederlandsch Indië. Door Dr. J. G. Boerlage. Tweede Deel, "Dicotyledones Gamopetala." Eerste Stuk, "Inferæ Heteromeræ; Caprifoliaceae-Styracaceæ." (Leyden : E. J. Brill, 1891.)

PREVIOUS parts of this work have been noticed in these columns. It is more than thirty years since the last part of Miquel's "Flora India Batavæ" appeared, a work written chiefly in Latin; but the present publication cannot be regarded as replacing it, or as being a successor to it. So far as we have tested this “Manual,” it is a Dutch translation of the descriptions of the natural orders and genera in Bentham and Hooker's "Genera Plantarum," followed by a list of the species inhabiting the Dutch Indies. Locally it may be serviceable; but what is wanted by botanists generally is a new descriptive elaboration of the species of the region in question. W. B. H. By Sea-shore, Wood, and Moorland: Peeps at Nature. By Edward Step. (London: S. W. Partridge and Co., 1891.)

THE author of this book, under his pseudonym "James Weston," published in 1886 "Stories and Pictures of Birds, Beasts, and Fishes"; and, two years later, a companion volume, "Stories and Pictures of Animal Life." Both of these volumes, which were very popular, are now out of print. In the present work they have been amalgamated, and the author has added to them some brief" nature-papers" which he has contributed to various periodicals. The book is intended chiefly for young people, and it is so pleasantly written that children who have a chance of reading it can hardly fail to find it attractive. They will obtain from it much interesting information about all sorts of animals, and it will help them to realize that even the most familiar objects, when properly observed, may be worthy of close study. The book is very carefully illustrated.

LETTERS TO THE EDITOR.

[The Editor does not hold himself responsible for opinions expressed by his correspondents. Neither can he undertake to return, or to correspond with the writers of, rejected manuscripts intended for this or any other part of NATURE. No notice is taken of anonymous communications.]

Note on the Chromosphere Spectrum. WITH the new spectroscope of the Halsted Observatory, which has a 5-inch Rowland grating of 20,000 lines to the inch, I have repeatedly observed of late that the bright chromosphere line, Angström 6676'9 (No. 2 in my catalogue of chromosphere lines), is not coincident with the corresponding dark line of the solar spectrum, but is less refrangible by about one-third of a unit of Rowland's scale. This chromosphere line, therefore, can no longer be ascribed to iron, but must be due to some other substance as yet undetermined.

I think there can be no doubt as to the non-coincidence. The interval between the bright and dark lines varies to some extent with circumstances, being usually less in the chromo

sphere spectrum on the sun's eastern limb than on the western, and it is often affected by motions in the line of sight; but nine times out of ten the want of coincidence is perfectly obvious. photographs of the ultra-violet spectrum of the chromosphere I may add that I have also obtained a considerable number of with the new instrument, and get complete confirmation of almost all Mr. Hale's results. I find not only the constant reversal of the H and K lines, but I have obtained, so far, five of the ultra violet series of hydrogen lines; the first of them being the well-known "companion" of H (first visually observed by myself in 1880), and the other four in their regular succession above it.

The only point in which my plates fail to confirm Mr. Hale's is that I have not yet succeeded in catching the duplicity of the hydrogen a (3889). Several of his plates show at this point two lines near together; none of mine do so, and I conclude that the companion line makes its appearance only rarely. I first observed this line visually in 1883 (American Journal of Science, November 1883), and it has since been often seen here by my as istant, Mr. Reed, as well as by myself.

Of course the opinion is no longer tenable that H and K can be due to hydrogen, since the measures clearly show that the companion to H belongs to the hydrogen series. But I am still sceptical whether they are due to calcium, at least in its terrestrial condition. C. A. YOUNG.

Princeton, N.J., U.S., October 20.

Formation of a Temporary Cyst in the Fresh-water Annelid Eolosoma.

As I am not aware that the formation of a temporary chitinous cyst has been described in any Oligochatous Annelid, the following observations may be of some little interest. A few days ago Mr. Latter, science master at the Charterhouse, kindly forwarded to me three tubes containing a quantity of Eolosoma quaternarium. They were so abundant that every drop of water contained several specimens; in the water I found also a still larger number of spherical bodies, which proved to be cysts, each completely filled by a single worm coiled once upon itself. The cysts were perfectly colourless and transparent, and very thin-walled; one cyst was found empty, and had been ruptured by the worm in escaping from it. Twenty-six years ago Maggi (Mem. Soc. Ital. Sci. Nat., 1865) described and figured some bodies, oval in form, which he believed to be the cocoons of Eolosoma; embryos were found in these cocoons in different stages of development. Prof. Vejdovsky (Entwickelungsgesch. Unters., Heft 1, Prag, 1888) suggested the possibility that these bodies were really cysts; my own examination of what are, I think, undoubtedly cysts in Eolosoma leads me to agree with Vejdovsky's suggested interpretation of Maggi's figures. If the structures which I describe here are really cocoons, their form differs from that of the cocoons of all other Oligochata, in being spherical and without a narrow process at either pole; moreover, it is-on the hypothesis that they are cocoons-a remarkable coincidence that they should all contain completely adult worms; finally, and this is of course conclusive, the intestinal tract of the worms contained vegetable detritus. The cysts, as I believe them to be, are of about the size of a Volvox globator. In this encysted condition the worms might perhaps be easily transported from place to place; I have found that they survived the evaporation of the surrounding water upon a glass slide for a considerable period; the worms were in continual movement within their cysts, so that it was quite easy to be sure that they

were alive. Now this very species has a wide distribution, which may perhaps be partially accounted for by this habit of encystment; with regard to other fresh-water Annelids which have a wide range, such as Tubifex, it is possible that birds may inadvertently transport the cocoons from country to country. It is not known yet whether Eolosoma forms a cocoon, though it is probable, as the worm develops a clitellum. But sexual maturity appears to be a comparatively rare occurrence in Eolosoma; very few observers appear to have seen the sexually mature worms. If this is so, the encystment of the worm may take the place of one of the secondary uses of the cocoon-namely, to aid in the diffusion of the species. FRANK E. Beddard.

Polytechnics and Recreation.

IN Mr. Oliver Dawson's article on Polytechnics in your issue of the 8th inst. (vol. xliv., p. 547) he says: “although

those institutes which make much of athleticism and such matters attract the largest proportion of students, the attend. ance pro ratâ in the class-rooms would not favourably compare with an institute carrying out a purely educational programme." A Polytechnic is mentioned in which, though only seven students entered the class, "scores of young men could be found in the billiard-room and gymnasium"; and the opinion is expressed that even the excellent work of the Regent Street Polytechnic "would be still better if it could be relieved of the recreative element."

[ocr errors]

May I say a word for recreation, as the representative of a College which will eventually form part of the South London Polytechnic, and which has not been "started by a teacher,' but has grown up out of a purely recreative institution, for the Victoria Hall (the parent of the Morley Memorial College) is nothing more, unless we use the word in a very narrow sense.

It is a commonplace truth that the aim of education should be to develop the whole man, not to make mere intellectual experts any more than mere manual experts. Surely recreation has not only a legitimate but a very important place in this, especially where sedentary workers are concerned. Those whose tastes are naturally studious may with comparative safety be left to take care of themselves. In these days, instruction of some sort may be had by most of those who set their minds on it, and if they miss much which books or the living teacher would have enabled them to gain, at least their energy is not likely to be turned into hurtful channels. Those who desire recreation can also get it, and with little exertion; but of what kind? If the gymnasium spoken of above had not been open, what would its scores of frequenters have been doing? Some, no doubt, might have been in class, improving their minds more than they are likely to do in a gymnasium; but others, whose youthful spirits need an outlet, would not have been much attracted by study not associated with recreation. The music-hall, or some of the many forms of betting now prevalent, would have been more likely to entice them. In the confined life of our towns it is no small good to provide athletic sports (apart from temptation to drink) as a safety-valve for boyish spirits, even if the good stops short there. But it need not stop short. Of course, there is danger lest the recreative side of an institute or Polytechnic should swamp the educational, unless care is taken to prevent it. A very simple rule, however, is sufficient for this. Our members are not allowed to use the gymnasium or recreation rooms unless they are bona fide students of at least one class. It is not sufficient that they should take a ticket for a class. The registers are occasionally looked over, and if frequent absence from class is combined with frequent attendance in the gymnasium or recreation rooms, a warning, suspension, or even expulsion, is the consequence. We have found that only in an insignificant number of cases is it necessary to proceed to the last resort. Our students as a rule receive an excellent character for steady work from such of our teachers as are in a position to compare them with other students. "I am tired of teaching lads who are trying not to learn," said one who held an important position in a large educational establishment; "your fellows mean And the testimony of business; it's a pleasure to teach them." others is to the same effect.

If the moving spirits of a Polytechnic love work themselves, and if they are careful to enlist the sympathy of students, so as to lead them by example rather than drive them by rigid rule, then there is little danger of the institution degenerating into a mere place of amusement. EMMA CONS. Samuel Morley Memorial College, Waterloo Road, S. E.,

October 16.

"W = Mg."

I SHOULD like to take exception to Prof. Greenhill's statement in your issue of September 24 (vol. xliv. p. 493) that "when goods are sold in commerce by weight, they are weighed in scales, and the weight is the same wherever the weighing is carried out, whether at the equator, or the poles, or in the Moon, Sun, or Jupiter." In this country it is the commonest thing in the world to see goods sold in commerce weighed in a spring-balance, which is also the universal kitchen weighing apparatus, and I respectfully submit that the weight indicated would not be quite the same in the Moon, Sun, or Jupiter.

The appeal to the scales seems to me to be an attempt to throw dust in our eyes, as what Prof. Greenhill really means is that two equal weights are equal (not each the same) wherever

the weighing is carried on-a balance telling us nothing about the weight, or pull downwards, of either one.

=

I was fortunate in getting some of my first notions of dynamical measurements from Thomson and Tait, and hence the appearance of the "blooming g" did not seem unnatural, for after I had learned how to measure a force properly in dynamical units, I was told that a pound's weight = g poundals, or a gram's weight g dynes, which suffices for reduction to non-absolute units. This, in my opinion, is virtually the same as Prof. Slate's suggestion. I never could see why g should appear in dynamical formulas: : measure in absolute units, and at the end reduce to pounds' weight from poundals as above. Of course this involves knowing what an absolute dynamical unit is, and it strikes me that a few more "horizontal" experiments with spring-balances, graduated in poundals or dynes, and a little less thinking about arm balances, would go far to clear up difficulties in the minds of students. ARTHUR G. WEBSTER.

Clark University, Worcester, Mass., October 14.

[It will be interesting to see if Mr. Webster can devise a horizontal spring dynamometer which will record within 10 per cent. of the true value; also to know what corrections he would apply for the inertia, temperature, and fatigue of the spring, and how he would occasionally test the indications. These difficulties have to be met in Diagrams given by SteamEngine Indicators. How does the Inspector of Weights and Measures test Spring-Balances in America?—A. G. G.]

Alum Solution.

PERHAPS the following evidence of the practical superiority of potash alum solution to distilled water in adiathermancy, when the electric arc is the radiant and the radiometer" a Crookes, may be of interest. The same glass-sided cell was used throughout, and the difference of voltage between the carbons ("Apostle ") was kept sensibly constant (40 volts) through the experiments. Between each observation on the liquids the glass of the radiometer, as recorded below. radiation from the arc was observed unimpeded, save by the The time was given by a metronome (previously examined for constancy) beating half-seconds.

No lens was used.

[blocks in formation]

The Salt Lake of Aalia Paakai.

I HAVE recently made an analysis of the water of the salt lake of Aalia Paakai, near Honolulu, and have thought that the results might be of interest to the readers of NATURE. The lake occupies the crater of an immense tufa cone, whose ejecta cover several square miles, and are especially remarkable for containing numerous aggregations of crystalline grains of pure olivine. The lake is just at mean sea-level, and is scarcely a mile distant from the ocean, but there is evidently no free communication with the waters of the sea.

During the dry months crusts of salt are deposited, sometimes six inches or more in thickness, on the bottom of the lake, and the salt has at times been taken out for use. In the rainy season the salt is wholly redissolved. The crust of salt is at the present

« AnteriorContinuar »