CASES DECIDED IN THE SUPREME COURT OF MICHIGAN FROM MARCH 16 TO MAY 26, 1909 HERSCHEL BOUTON LAZELL STATE REPORTER VOL. 156 FIRST EDITION CHICAGO During the illness of Mr. Lazell, the Reports were compiled by Copyright, 1909, by Frederick C. Martindale, Secretary of State, for the State of Michigan. DEC 15 1909 PRINTED AND BOUND BY LANSING, MICHIGAN. CLAUDIUS B. GRANT, MARQUETTE, Dec. 31, 1909 CLERK—CHARLES C. HOPKINS, LANSING. | ANDREW B. CHAPIN," LANSING. Š. CRIE ATTORNEY GENERAL-JOHN E. BIRD, ADRIAN. Pursuant to Act No. 182, Public Acts 1893, the Justices reside at Lansing during their terms of office. Resigned April 1, 1909. 'Appointed May 26, 1909. CIRCUIT JUDGES. 1. 2. 4. in co JACKSON. HASTINGS. PONTIAC FLINT IONIA. KALAMAZOO. co si GUY M, CHESTER, ORVILLE W. COOLIDGE, . (ALFRED J. MURPHY, GEORGE S. HOSMER, HENRY A. MANDELL, JOSEPH W. DONOVAN. MORSE ROHNERT, (JAMES 0. MURFIN.1 JAMES A. PARKINSON, CLEMENT SMITH, GEORGE W. SMITH, . CHARLES H. WISNER, FRANK D. M. DAVIS, FRANK E. KNAPPEN, . WILLIAM G. GAGE, CHAUNCEY H. GAGE, WILLIAM R. KENDRICK, JOSEPH H. STEERE, . . ALBERT T. STREETER, . FREDERICK W. MAYNE, CLARENCE W. SESSIONS, GEORGE L. YAPLE, . . BYRON R. ERSKINE, .. (JOHN S. MODONALD, ) | WILLIS B. PERKINS, S. CHESTER L. COLLINS, . CHARLES H, ROSE, PHILIP PADGHAM, . PETER F. DODDS, . EDWARD D. KINNE, .. MAIN J. CONNINE, .. WATSON BEACH, JOHN W. STONE, FRANK EMERICK, . . LEWIS G. PALMER, . . CLYDE C. CHITTENDEN, KELLEY S. SEARL, . . SAULT STE. MARIE. o GRAND RAPIDS. 1 Elected for unexpired term April 5, 1909. 2 Died April 7, 1909. 3 Appointed to fill vacancy April 19, 1909. |