kin, 83 Ala. 142, 3 So. 296, 3 Am. St. Rep. 702; Kiser v. Gamble, 75 Ala. 386; Bradley v. Ragsdale, 64 Ala. 558; Pickett v. Pipkin, 64 Ala. 520; Coleman v. Smith, 55 Ala. 368; Governor v. Campbell, 17 Ala. 566; Borland v. Mayo, 8 Ala. 104; Stover v. Herrington, 7 Ala. 142, 41 Am. Dec.

86.

Ark.-Wallace V. Bernheim, 63 Ark. 108, 37 S. W. 712; Erb v. Cole, 31 Ark. 554; Galbreath v. Cook, 30 Ark. 417; De Prato v. Jester (1892), 20 S. W. 807.

Cal. Grunsky v. Perlin, 110 Cal. 179, 42 Pac. 575; Priest v. Brown, 100 Cal. 626, 35 Pac. 323; Cohen v. Knox, 90 Cal. 266, 27 Pac. 215, 13 L. R. A. 711.

Colo.-Riethmann v. Godsman, 23 Colo. 202, 46 Pac. 686.

75

Conn.-Unmack v. Douglass, Conn. 633, 55 Atl. 12; Knower v. Cadden Clothing Co., 57 Conn. 202, 17 Atl. 580; Sisson v. Roath, 30 Conn. 15.

D. C.-Droop v. Ridenour, 11 App. Cas. 224; Birdsall v. Welch, 6 D. C. 316.

Ga.-Hollis v. Sales, 103 Ga. 75, 29 S. E. 482.

Ill.-Hughes v. Noyes, 171 Ill. 575, 49 N. E. 703; Marmon v. Harwood, 124 III. 104, 16 N. E. 236, 7 Am. St. Rep. 345; Schroeder v. Walsh, 120 Ill. 403, 11 N. E. 70; Sawyer v. Moyer, 109 Ill. 461; Seeders v. Allen, 98 Ill. 468; Jewett v. Cook, 81 Ill. 260; Hatch v. Jordan, 74 Ill. 414; Miller v. Kirby, 74 Ill. 242; Mathes v. Dobschuetz, 72 Ill. 438; Herkelrath v. Stookey, 63 Ill. 486; Gridley v. Bingham, 51 Ill. 153; Hessing v. McCloskey, 37 Ill. 341; Meixsell v.

Williamson, 35 Ill. 529; Myers v. Kinzie, 26 Ill. 36; Brown v. Riley, 22 Ill. 45; Ewing v. Runkle, 20 Ill. 448; Eickstraedt v. Moses, 105 Ill. App. 634; Edwards v. Story, 105 Ill. App. 433; Ball v. Callahan, 95 Ill. App. 615; Johnston v. Hirschberg, 85 Ill. App. 47; Oakford v. Dunlap, 63 Ill. App. 498; Rhoades, etc., Co. v. Smith, 43 Ill. App. 400; Griffin v. Wolf, 31 Ill. App. 554.

Ind.-Hedrick v. Hall, 155 Ind. 371, 58 N. E. 257; Marmon v. White, 151 Ind. 445, 51 N. E. 930; Straight v. Roberts, 126 Ind. 383, 26 N. E. 73; Neisler v. Harris, 115 Ind. 560, 18 N. E. 39; First Nat. Bank v. Carter, 89 Ind. 317; Trentman v. Swartzell, 85 Ind. 443; Moore v. Lampton, 80 Ind. 301; Brown v. Rawlings, 72 Ind. 505; Spaulding v. Myers, 64 Ind. 264; Johnston v. Field, 62 Ind. 377; Kyger v. F. Hull Skirt Co., 34 Ind. 249; McCormick v. Hyatt, 33 Ind. 546; Palmer v. Henderson, 20 Ind. 297; Ewing v. Gray, 12 Ind. 64; Stewart v. English, 6 Ind. 176; Doe v. Horn, 1 Ind. 363, 50 Am. Dec. 470; South Bend Iron Works Co. v. Duddleson (App. 1891), 27 N. E. 312; Wilson v. Clark, 1 Ind. App. 182, 27 N. E. 310.

Ind. T.-Purcell Wholesale Grocery Co. v. Bryant (1905), 89 S. W. 662.

Iowa.-Atkinson v. McNider (1905), 105 N. W. 504; Urdangen & Greenberg Bros. v. Doner, 122 Iowa, 533, 98 N. W. 917; Thompson v. Zuckmayer (1903), 94 N. W. 476; Brooks v. Jones, 114 Iowa, 385, 82 N. W. 434, 86 N. W. 300; Roberts v. Press, 97 Iowa, 475, 66 N. W. 756; Davis v. Garrison, 85 Iowa, 447, 52 N. W. 359; Stroff v. Swafford, 81 Iowa,

V.

Kan.-Parmenter V. Lomax, 68 Kan. 61, 74 Pac. 634; Schram v. Taylor, 51 Kan. 547, 33 Pac. 315; Farlin v. Sook, 30 Kan. 401, 1 Pac. 123, 46 Am. Rep. 100; Wilson v. Fuller, 9 Kan. 176; Diefendorf v. Oliver, 8 Kan. 365; Roach v. Barry, 5 Kan. App. 879, 48 Pac. 866.

Ky.-Anglin v. Conley, 27 Ky. L. Rep. 1177, 87 S. W. 1137, 24 Ky. L. Rep. 1551, 71 S. W. 926; Beadles v. Miller, 51 Ky. 32; Brown v. Smith, 46 Ky. 361; Brown v. Foree, 46 Ky. 357, 46 Am. Dec. 519; Boyce v. Waller, 41 Ky. 91; Violett v. Violett, 32 Ky. 323; Carter v. Richardson, 22 Ky. L. Rep. 1204, 60 S. W. 397; American Brewing Co. v. McGruder, 17 Ky. L. Rep. 762, 32 S. W. 603; Farmers', etc., Nat. Bank v. Connor, 13 Ky. L. Rep. 592; Meyer v. Specker, 10 Ky. L. Rep. 116; Wiseman v. McAlpin, 6 Ky. L. Rep. 660; Allen v. Gilliland, 5 Ky. L. Rep. 320; Ferguson v. May, 4 Ky. L. Rep. 989.

La.-Chaffe v. Gill, 43 La. Ann. 1054, 10 So. 361; Lowenstein v. Fudickar, 43 La. Ann. 886, 9 So. 742; Leen Kee v. Smith, 35 La. Ann. 518; Bastian v. Christesen, 34 La. Ann. 883; Montgomery v. Wilson, 31 La. Ann. 196; Shultz v. Morgan, 27 La. Ann. 616; Billgery v. Schnell, 26 La. Ann. 467; Southern Dry Dock Co. v. Bayou Sara Packet Co., 24 La. Ann.

141; Planters' Bank v. Watson, 9 Rob. 267; Barrett v. His Creditors, 4 Rob. 408; Thompson v. Gordon, 12 La. 260; Rhodes v. Beaman, 10 La. 363; McManus v. Jewett, 9 La. 170; Bauduc v. His Creditors, 4 La. 247; Kenney v. Dow, 10 Mart. 577, 13 Am. Dec. 342.

Me.-Tolman v. Ward, 86 Me. 303, 29 Atl. 1081, 41 Am. St. Rep. 556; Stevens v. Hinckley, 43 Me. 440; Davis v. Tibbetts, 39 Me. 279.

Md.-Crooks v. Brydon, 93 Md. 640, 49 Atl. 921; Cooke v. Cooke, 43 Md. 522; Troxall v. Applegarth, 24 Md. 163; Waters v. Riggin, 19 Md.

536.

Mass.-Russell v. Cole, 167 Mass. 6, 44 N. E. 1057, 57 Am. St. Rep. 432; Morse v. Aldrich, 130 Mass. 578; Snow v. Paine, 114 Mass. 520; Hamilton v. Cone, 99 Mass. 478; Green v. Tanner, 49 Mass. 411; Foster v. Hall, 29 Mass. 89, 22 Am. Dec. 400; Kittredge v. Sumner, 28 Mass. 50; Harrison v. Phillips Academy, 12 Mass. 456.

Mich.-Delavan v. Wright, 110 Mich. 143, 67 N. W. 1110; Spring Lake Ins. Co. v. Waters, 50 Mich. 13, 14 N. W. 679.

Miss.-Osborn v. McCallum (1905), 38 So. 609; Tennent-Stribling Shoe Co. v. Davie, 75 Miss. 447, 23 So. 188; Ladnier v. Ladnier, 64 Miss. 368, 1 So. 492; Ewing v. Cargill, 13 Sm. & M. 79; Pope v. Andrews, S. & M. Ch. 135; Bernheim v. Dibrell (1892), 11 So. 795.

Mo.-Mansur-Tebbetts

Implement

Co. v. Ritchie, 159 Mo. 213, 60 S. W. 87; Alberger v. White, 117 Mo. 347, 23 S. W. 92; State v. Mason, 112 Mo.

374, 20 S. W. 629, 34 Am. St. Rep. 390; State v. Hope, 102 Mo. 410, 14 S. W. 985; Hurley v. Taylor, 78 Mo. 238; Byrne v. Becker, 42 Mo. 264; Wise v. Wimer, 23 Mo. 237; Little v. Eddy, 14 Mo. 160; Kelly-Goodfellow Shoe Co. v. Vail, 84 Mo. App. 94; Wachtel v. Ewing, 82 Mo. App. 594; Esselbruegge Mercantile Co. v. Troll, 79 Mo. App. 558; Simon-Gregory Dry Goods Co. v. Schooley, 66 Mo. App. 406; Pierson v. Slifer, 52 Mo. App. 273; Gens v. Hargadine, 45 Mo. App. 38; Hausmann v. Hope, 20 Mo. App. 193.

Mont.-Curtis v. Valiton, 3 Mont.

153.

Neb.-Farmers', etc., Nat. Bank v. Mosher, 63 Neb. 130, 88 N. W. 552; Steinberg v. Buffum, 61 Neb. 778, 86 N. W. 491; Powell v. Yeazel, 46 Neb. 225, 64 N. W. 695; Blumer v. Bennett, 44 Neb. 873, 63 N. W. 14; Edwards v. Reid, 39 Neb. 645, 58 N. W. 202, 42 Am. St. Rep. 607; Farrington v. Stone, 35 Neb. 456, 53 N. W. 389; Crabb v. Morrisey, 31 Neb. 161, 47 N. W. 697; Hedman v. Anderson, 6 Neb. 392.

Nev.-Gregory v. Frothingham, 1 Nev. 253.

N. H.-Currier v. Taylor, 19 N. H. 189; Badger v. Story, 16 N. H. 168.

N. J.-Kinmonth v. White (Ch. 1900), 47 Atl. 1; Flemington Nat. Bank v. Jones, 50 N. J. Eq. 244, 24 Atl. 928; Mathiez v. Day, 36 N. J. Eq. 88; Roe v. Moore, 35 N. J. Eq. 526; New York Fire Ins. Co. v. Tooker, 35 N. J. Eq. 408; Muirhead v. Smith, 35 N. J. Eq. 303; First Nat. Bank v. Irons, 28 N. J. Eq. 43, 625; Tantum v. Green, 21 N. J. Eq. 364; Atwood v. Impson, 20 N. J. Eq. 150.

N. C.-Wolf v. Arthur, 118 N. C. 890, 24 S. E. 671; Nadal v. Britton, 112 N. C. 180, 16 S. E. 914; Woodruff v. Bowles, 104 N. C. 197, 10 S. E. 482; Brown v. Mitchell, 102 N. C. 347, 9 S. E. 702, 11 Am. St. Rep. 748; Beasley v. Bray, 98 N. C. 266, 3 S. E. 497; Savage v. Knight, 92 N. C. 493, 53 Am. Rep. 423; Tredwell v. Graham, 88 N. C. 208; Lassiter v. Davis, 64 N. C. 498. Ohio.-Bancroft V. Blizzard, 13 Ohio, 30.

Okla.-McFadyen V. Masters, 8 Okla. 174, 56 Pac. 1059; Kansas Moline Prow Co. v. Sherman, 3 Okla. 204, 41 Pac. 623, 32 L. R. A. 33; Jackson v. Glaze, 3 Okla. 143, 41 Pac. 79; Chandler v. Colcord, 1 Okla. 260, 32 Pac. 330.

Or.-Livesley v. Heise (1906), 85 Pac. 509; Jennings v. Frazier (1905), 80 Pac. 1011; Garnier v. Wheeler, 40 Or. 198, 66 Pac. 812; Sabin v. Columbia Fuel Co., 25 Or. 15, 34 Pac. 692, 42 Am. St. Rep. 756; Bonser v. Miller, 5 Or. 110.

Pa.-Snayberger v. Fahl, 195 Pa. St. 336, 45 Atl. 1065, 78 Am. St. Rep. 818; Werner v. Zierfuss, 162 Pa. St. 360, 29 Atl. 737; Thompson v. Lee, 3 Watts & S. 479; Towar v. Barrington, Brightley N. P. 253. See Helfrich v. Stem, 17 Pa. St. 143.

S. C.-McElwee v. Kennedy, 56 S. C. 154, 34 S. E. 86; Weinges v. Cash, 15 S. C. 44; Means v. Feaster, 4 S. C. 249.

Tenn.-Jones v. Cullen, 100 Tenn. 1, 42 S. W. 873.

Tex.-Sanger v. Colbert, 84 Tex. 688, 19 S. W. 863; Dodd v. Gaines, 82 Tex. 429, 18 S. W. 618; Le Page v. Slade, 79 Tex. 473, 15 S. W. 496;

Tillman v. Heller (1890), 14 S. W. 271; Hadock v. Hill, 75 Tex. 193, 12 S. W. 974; Collins v. Cook, 40 Tex. 238; Mills v. Howeth, 19 Tex. 257, 70 Am. Dec. 331; Matador Land & Cattle Co. v. Cooper (Civ. App. 1905), 87 S. W. 235; Wade v. Odle, 21 Tex. Civ. App. 656, 54 S. W. 786; Koch v. Bruce, 20 Tex. Civ. App. 634, 49 S. W. 1101; Garahy v. Bayley, 25 Tex. Suppl. 294; Mills v. Waller, Dall. 416; Hillboldt v. Waugh (Civ. App. 1898), 47 S. W. 829; Tempel v. Dodge, 11 Tex. Civ. App. 42, 31 S. W. 686; Cox v. Morrison (Civ. App. 1895), 31 S. W. 67; Dittman v. Weiss (Civ. App. 1895), 31 S. W. 67; Ward v. Wofford (Civ. App. 1894), 26 S. W. 321; Bailey v. Crittenden, 3 Tex. Civ. App. Cas., § 179. Vt.-Wilson v. Spear, 68 Vt. 145, 34 Atl. 429; Leach v. Francis, 41 Vt. 670.

Va.-Wheby v. Moir, 102 Va. 875, 47 S. E. 1005; Merchants' Bank v. Belt (1898), 30 S. E. 467; Clay v. Walter, 79 Va. 92.

W. Va.-R. M. Sutton & Co. v. Christie (1906), 53 S. E. 602; Dent v. Pickens (1906), 53 S. E. 154; Timms v. Timms, 54 W. Va. 414, 46 S. E. 141; Baer Sons Grocer Co. v. Williams, 43 W. Va. 323, 27 S. E. 345; Casto v. Fry, 33 W. Va. 449, 10 S. E. 799; Lockhard v. Beckley, 10 W. Va. 87; Bishoff v. Hartley, 9 W. Va. 100; Hill v. Ruffner, 3 W. Va. 538.

Wis.-Bannister v. Phelps, 81 Wis. 256, 51 N. W. 417; Second Nat. Bank v. Merrill, 81 Wis. 142, 50 N. W. 503, 29 Am. St. Rep. 870; Mehlhop v. Pettibone, 54 Wis. 652, 11 S. W. 553, 12 N. W. 443; Hopkins v. Langton, 30 Wis. 379. See Bleiler v. Moore, 94

Wis. 385, 69 N. W. 164; Shoemaker v. Katz, 74 Wis. 374, 43 N. W. 151. Can.-Smith v. Moffatt, 28 U. C. Q. B. 486, 27 U. C. Q. B. 195; Bank of Montreal v. Condon, 11 Manitoba, 366; Tucker v. Young, Manitoba T. Wood, 186; Mason v. Scott, 20 Grant Ch. (U. C.) 84; Allan v. McTavish, 8 Ont. App. 440; Brown v. Sweet, 7 Ont. App. 725.

Eng. In re Reis (1904), 2 K. B. 769, 73 L. J. K. B. 929, 91 L. T. Rep. N. S. 592, 11 Manson, 229, 20 L. T. Rep. 547, 53 Wkly. Rep. 122; Halifax Banking Co. v. Gledhill (1891), 1 Ch. 31, 60 L. J. Ch. 181, 63 L. T. Rep. N. S. 623, 39 Wkly. Rep. 104; Parnell v. Stedman, 1 Cab. & E. 153; Golden v. Gillam, 51 L. J. Ch. 503, 20 Ch. 389, 51 L. J. Ch. 154, 46 L. T. Rep. N. S. 222.

30. N. Y.-Fuller Electrical Co. v. Lewis, 101 N. Y. 674, 5 N. E. 437; Metcalf v. Moses, 35 App. Div. 596, 55 N. Y. Supp. 179; Smith v. Post, 3 Thomps. & C. 647.

Ark.-Cornish v. Dews, 18 Ark.

Del.-Slessinger v. Topkis, 1 Marv. 140, 40 Atl. 717; Gamble v. Harris, 5 Del. Ch. 512.

Ga.-Newhoff v. Clegg, 99 Ga. 167, 25 S. E. 184.

Ill.-Young v. Clapp, 147 Ill. 176, 32 N. E. 187, 35 N. E. 372; School Trustees v. Mason (1887), 13 N. E. 235; Webber v. Mackey, 31 Ill. App. 369.

Ind.-Pinnell v. Stringer, 59 Ind.

555.

Ind. T.-Purcell Wholesale Grocery Co. v. Bryant (1905), 89 S. W. 662.

Iowa.-Mills v. Miller, 109 Iowa, 688, 81 N. W. 169; Cox v. Collis, 109 Iowa, 270, 80 N. W. 343; Roberts v. Press, 97 Iowa, 475, 66 N. W. 756; Kohn v. Clement, 58 Iowa, 589, 12 N. W. 550; Moss v. Dearing, 45 Iowa, 530.

Kan.-Davis v. McCarthy, 52 Kan. 116, 34 Pac. 399.

Ky.-Foster v. Grigsby, 64 Ky. 86; Ford v. Williams, 42 Ky. 550.

Mich.-Franklin Needle Co. V. Amazon Hosiery Co., 128 Mich. 198, 87 N. W. 211; Andrews v. Fillmore, 46 Mich. 315, 9 N. W. 431; Beurmann v. Van Buren, 44 Mich. 496, 7 N. W. 67.

Mo.-Byrne v. Becker, 42 Mo. 264; Chouteau v. Sherman, 11 Mo. 385; Frank v. Curtis, 58 Mo. App. 349; Kendall v. Baltis, 26 Mo. App. 411. Neb.-National Bank of Commerce v. Chapman, 50 Neb. 484, 70 S. W. 39; Hedman v. Anderson, 6 Neb. 392.

N. J.-Platt v. McClong (Ch. 1901), 49 Atl. 1125; Folk v. Fonda (Ch. 1894), 29 Atl. 676; Demarest v. Terhune, 18 N. J. Eq. 45.

N. C.-Battle v. Mayo, 102 N. C. 413, 9 S. E. 384. But see Mitchell v. Eure, 126 N. C. 77, 35 S. E. 190.

Pa.-Magee v. Raiguel, 64 Pa. St. 110; Greenwalt v. Austin, 1 Grant, 169; Jennings v. Smith, 22 Pa. Co. Ct. 554, 30 Pitts. L. J. 125.

8. C.-Anderson v. Pilgram, 41 S. C. 423, 19 S. E. 1002, 20 S. E. 64; Smith v. Pate, 3 S. C. 204.

Tenn.-Wilson v. Eifler, 47 Tenn. 31.

32

Tex.-Galveston Dry Goods Co. v. Blum, 23 Tex. Civ. App. 703, 57 S. W. 1121; White v. Sterzing, 11 Tex. Civ. App. 553, 32 S. W. 909; Lewis v. Alexander (Civ. App. 1895), 31 S. W. 414.

Va.-Oberdorfer v. Meyer, 88 Va. 384, 13 S. E. 756.

Wash.-Samuel

v. Kittenger, 6 Wash. 261, 33 Pac. 509.

W. Va.-Baer Sons Grocer Co. v. Williams, 43 W. Va. 323, 27 S. E. 345.

Wis.-Dornbrook v. M. Rumely Co., 120 Wis. 36, 97 N. W. 493.

31. See cases cited in last two preceding notes.

32. N. Y.-Beals v. Guernsey, Johns. 446, 5 Am. Dec. 348.

U. S.-Means v. Montgomery, 23 Fed. 421; Wilson v. Prewett, 30 Fed. Cas. No. 17,828, 3 Woods, 631, rev'd Prewit v. Wilson, 103 U. S. 22, 26 L. Ed. 360.

Ala.-Marshall v. Croom, 52 Ala.

554.

Ark. Trieber v. Andrews, 31 Ark. 163; Splawn v. Martin, 17 Ark. 146. Conn.-Partelo v. Harris, 26 Conn.

480.

Ga.-Claflin v. Ballance, 91 Ga. 411, 18 S. E. 309.

Ill.-Rothgerber v. Gough, 52 Ill. 436; Aultman & Taylor Co. v. Weir, 34 Ill. App. 615; Webber v. Mackey, 31 Ill. App. 369.

Ind. Scott v. Davis, 117 Ind. 232, 26 N. E. 139.

Kan.-La Clef v. Campbell, 3 Kan. App. 756, 45 Pac. 461.

Me.-Blodgett v. Chaplin, 48 Me.