...former may have gained what the other has tot." * "The man of knowledge and the productive labourer come to be widely divided from each other, and knowledge, instead of remaining the handmaid of labour in the hand of the labourer to increase his productive powers ... has almost everywhere arrayed...

...anticipating Harry Braverman, William Thompson observes: The man of knowledge and the productive labourer come to be widely divided from each other, and knowledge, instead of remaining the handmaid of labour in the hand of the labourer to increase his productive powers . . . has almost everywhere arrayed...

...1824 a lament that the radical science movement of the 1960s and the 1970s would easily recognize: 'The man of knowledge and the productive laborer come...hand of the laborer to increase his productive powers . . . has almost everywhere arrayed itself against labor. . . . Knowledge [becomes] an instrument,...

...subsequently assigned to functionaries. Thus, as Marx quoted William Thompson, a socialist precursor, "The man of knowledge and the productive laborer come...knowledge, instead of remaining the handmaid of labor . . . has almost everywhere arrayed itself against labor."48 That was for Marx the end of the matter,...

...former may have gained what the other has lost." 1 "The man of knowledge and the productive labourer come to be widely divided from each other, and knowledge, instead of remaining the handmaid of labour in the hand of the labourer to increase his productive powers . . . has almost everywhere arrayed...